Honest Advertising – An Oxymoron?
By Sheila on Dec 4, 2009 in Advertising Tips
One of the greatest moments in blogging history was when the FCC ruled that bloggers had to disclose their relationships with advertisers. Bloggers must now disclose if they are receiving free products or perks in exchange for write-ups and reviews. The rules extend to Facebook, Twitter and other social media outlets. I cannot tell you how many times I got annoyed when I spent a few minutes drawn into what I thought was an inspired post only to find out that it was a paid review – once I realize it’s a paid review I just think that whatever the post says it is probably BS, either a real stretch or an outright lie – even if the writer didn’t make up the information in the article I am left feeling like I somehow had the wool pulled over my eyes. (I know this doesn’t apply to everyone out there doing paid reviews, but when I read an article from someone in the Phillipines raving about some lawyer in the US I get annoyed) Sometimes it happens often enough that I won’t revisit a site. But, with the new rule in place I know ahead of time that the article is a paid review and I can make the decision whether or not to read on, and, sometimes I do.
It’s all about honesty in advertising. Don’t try to trick me. Do advertisers really believe the public is so stupid? They may be able to fool people for a while, but eventually we catch on and then your screwed.
How about some real honest advertising?




Here is some advice for advertisers from the BBB -
Advertising is an essential part of business; not only can it attract new customers or clients, but it can also leave a lasting impression of a business’ brand or reputation. Misleading or unclear advertising can lead to unhappy customers.
BBB encourages self-regulation: Ultimately, the primary responsibility for truthful and non-deceptive advertising rests with the advertiser.
Your Better Business Bureau serving Alaska, Oregon, and Western Washington provides the following guidance about advertising phrases and tactics that can be misleading to consumers if not used properly:
- FREE may be used whenever the advertiser is offering an unconditional and temporary gift, not a continuous combination offer. If an additional item must be purchased in order to receive a gift, such as “buy one, get one free,” the advertiser must clearly disclose the conditions. In addition, an advertiser may not increase the price of the purchased item, nor decrease quantity or quality in conjunction with the free offer.
- PRICE-REDUCTION CLAIMS such as “save up to …,” should state both the minimum and maximum savings. The offer should not over emphasize the maximum savings value in a misleading manner. For example: An advertiser should not imply that the majority of the items on the sales rack are 50 percent off, when only 2 out of the 30 items are on sale for that discount. The number of items available at the maximum savings should comprise at least 10 percent of all the sale merchandise (unless local or state law requires otherwise).
- LOWEST PRICES for products and services fluctuate regularly and it can be extremely difficult to claim, with certainty, that prices are lower than a competitors. Such claims should be avoided unless the advertiser can provide substantiation.
- BAIT AND SWITCH is an illegal tactic in which an ad “baits” consumers with an alluring but insincere offer for a product or service that the company does not intend to sell. Instead, they “switch” and attempt to convince consumers to buy it at a higher price. In other situations, the same price is offered, but the item or service is a lower quality than what was advertised.
- GUARANTEES AND WARRANTIES like “satisfaction guaranteed” and similar representations should be used in advertising only if the seller or manufacturer refunds the full purchase price at the buyer’s request. A “lifetime guarantee” should clearly and prominently disclose the exact length of time the offer is valid. Any material limitations or conditions should be clearly and prominently disclosed, with complete details made accessible at the advertiser’s store or on their Web site prior to the sale of the service or product. In the case of mail or telephone order sales, the full guarantee or warranty should be available free upon request.









5 Comment(s)
By fedhz on Dec 4, 2009 | Reply
I do paid posts. I don’t write BS and I’m not good in writing reviews. So I choose the tasks to write. I prefer advertisers who just want their links be placed in the blog post. ^^
By Chinaren on Dec 5, 2009 | Reply
Whilst this will affect a fair amount of blogs, you must remember there’s a lot of people not in the US, or using servers in the US, so it’s hardly going to stop everyone.
Also I doubt they’re really going to police it heavily!
So basically it’s one more waste of time.
To be honest most paid posts have about three links that immediately mark them as such, and are written in such a way it’s fairly obvious what they are.
By Sheila on Dec 5, 2009 | Reply
You’re right, a lot of people aren’t in the US – so maybe it won’t make that big of a difference. But, I have noticed that quite a few blogs are using this and I have to say that I really appreciate it when it is put out there that it is a paid post.
It’s better than not doing anything at all.
By Man Over Board on Dec 5, 2009 | Reply
To me it’s just one more thing that Big Brother has to stick their nose into and threaten people with penalties. You said it in this post already, most of us know or can assume that the post has some sort of advertising involved in it’s message. And for those who cannot figure that out, probably are still buying war bonds.
By Mar Matthias Darin on Dec 9, 2009 | Reply
Hi,
I’ve always had an open policy with my blog. It just works better with the visitors… False advertising is garbage no matter where it occurs. I even use an open and transparent policy with my traffic sharing program, “Along for the Ride!”
Its all about building a good reputation. A good reputation brings visitors and advertisers.